In January 2023, researchers at Stanford University published a study in the journal Cell Reports Medicine that quickly spread across the world. The question was simple: which breathing exercise has the best effect on mood and stress – and is breathing better than meditation?
How the study was done
The participants were split into four groups. Everyone did five minutes of exercise every day for a month:
- Cyclic sighing: two inhales through the nose and a long exhale through the mouth.
- Box breathing: equal inhale, hold, exhale and hold.
- Cyclic hyperventilation with breath hold: deep, fast breaths followed by a breath hold, in the style of the Wim Hof method.
- Mindfulness meditation.
For adults with some experience: one email every morning for 14 days – no time targets, never in water.
The results
All the groups had improved mood and less anxiety. But the breathing exercises gave more positive mood than meditation – and cyclic sighing had the biggest effect. Cyclic sighing also gave the largest drop in resting breathing rate, a sign that the body became calmer.
Why does the sigh work?
The double inhale fills the air sacs in the lungs that have collapsed a little, and the long exhale activates the part of the nervous system that calms things down (the parasympathetic). The body does the same by itself when we cry or fall asleep. In 2016 the neuroscientists Jack Feldman and Mark Krasnow found the nerve cells in the brainstem that control sighing.
Try it now
Breathe in through your nose. Take one more small sip of air at the top. Breathe out slowly through your mouth. Do it three times. Can you feel the difference?
Follow the breathing guide for the physiological sigh, or do five minutes of cyclic sighing with us.
Top image: Palm trees at sunset (see image credits). This article is general information and does not replace medical advice.